The SpannerWorks!

Review added January 13, 2005.         Men in Black Limited Edition :: DVD Review  

<< Back to Main Page  

.
.
   
Studio: Columbia TriStar >> Review Equipment
Video: 1.85:1 (Enhanced for 16:9) Length: 94 Minutes
Audio: Dolby Digital 5.1 (384kbps) Eng/Fr/De Subtitles: Eng/Fr/Por/De/Du/Sv/No/Fi/Cz
Dolby Digital 2.0 (192kbps) Eng Dan/Pol/Hu/Ice/Heb/Hi/Ar/Bu
Video Format: PAL Disc Format: RSDL DVD-18
Layer Change: 47:11 Disc Capacity Utilised: X.XGB
Average Bit-Rate (A+V): X.XMbps Region Coding: 2/4
     
.
.

:: The Film ::

 
 

>> Skip to Audio/Video Details

After a three year delay, courtesy of Steven Spielberg's Amblin Entertainment, Men In Black has finally arrived on DVD. Men In Black was for a time Columbia TriStar's highest grossing blockbuster film, and announced as one of their first DVD titles back in 1997 when the young format's future was far from secure. I eagerly awaited the disc's arrival, having just bought my first DVD player, but the title was cancelled mere weeks from its announced release date.

Oh well, better late than never I guess. Men In Black's super-hip dialogue, cool premise and killer cast (including the then red hot Will Smith, fresh from 'Independence Day') virtually guaranteed the film would be a box-office success. As an added bonus Men In Black turned out to be a genuinely entertaining little film (and I do mean little, the film's running time, minus end credits, clocks in at only 87 minutes). 
 



Its sense of humour is quirky, ranging from the subtle to the obvious, a sense of humour enhanced enormously by Tommy Lee Jones' deadpan performance: the perfect counter to Will Smith playing, well, Will Smith. Men In Black's other standout performance comes courtesy of Vincent D'Onofrio, whose portrayal of 'Edgar' is truly amazing. Add some great CGI effects and tight direction by Barry Sonnenfeld ('The Addams Family', 'Get Shorty') into the mix, and you have a film that's sure to entertain.  
 

  :: Video ::
.
.


 

Hmm, I wonder what happens when Columbia TriStar, one of the kings of the DVD format, decide to release their highest grossing film of all time on said format? Will it look any good? Is the Earth round? Well, all joking aside, the answer is an emphatic "yes". This is a very good transfer indeed, and well up to Columbia TriStar's usual high standards; if not quite as good as the very best. There's nothing much to complain about here: the picture is very sharp, with lots of fine detail and few distractions in the way of film artefacts.

Colours are vibrant and clean, ranging from the subdued to the spectacular, the entire range of which are handled with ease. Blacks are deep and stable, shadow detail is above average, and I couldn't spot any aliasing or shimmer no matter how hard I looked. The only things depriving this transfer of reference status are a few minor niggles with skin tones, and some slight edge enhancement. The edge enhancement is very subtle, and I doubt most viewers would even notice it; as is the variation of skin tones, which manifests itself as slightly pale or slightly green skin tones in interior sequences. Skin tones and the film's general colour palette look very similar to those in Barry Sonnenfeld's 'The Addams Family', so may be an artistic decision. Grain is occasionally visible, but not distracting, and the grain visible at 26:48 is about as bad as it gets, which isn't too bad at all. This is a cracking transfer, and earns four and a half stars.
 

.
.
  :: Audio ::
.
.



 


The best word to describe this disc's Dolby Digital 5.1 soundtrack is "fun". Like the disc's video transfer, this soundtrack is very good. Surround effects stretch across the front channels, and extend right around to the surround soundstage. Naturally, the front soundstage contains many accurate audio pans and directional effects, and dialogue is always clear, but sounds a little harsh. The surround channels are used throughout the film, and the front and rear channels blend superbly, often producing phantom front/rear sound effects, truly enveloping the listener in sound.

The surround channels contain quite a few discrete effects, but often blend into the background, filling the room with discreet ambient effects. Left alone, the surrounds don't overtly call attention to themselves, but turn them off and the soundfield collapses quite dramatically into the front soundstage: always the sign of good surround channel use in my books.

One of the soundtrack's biggest pluses is the bass on offer: deep, well controlled and "punchy", for lack of a better word. The LFE channel is used extensively to support both music and audio effects, and often reaches down to subterranean depths. Listen to the descending bass tones produced whenever the MiBs' car is turned off, or supporting the score during the film's opening credits: impressive, and extension well below 30Hz. This is the sort of stuff that makes you glad you ponied up the cash for a decent subwoofer. Dynamic range is very good, and louder scenes may have some grabbing for the volume dial. I noted some minor distortion in the left surround channel at 22:44-22:53, but it seems to be an isolated incident. Five stars.
 

.
.

.


All material in this site copyright Adam Barratt

Back to Main Page